基于歷史文化的闡釋：文化詩學(xué)的方法論探究
發(fā)布時(shí)間：2018-12-17 06:58
【摘要】：格林布拉特稱"文化詩學(xué)"為"一種實(shí)踐,而不是一種教義"。文化詩學(xué)以其方法論層面的實(shí)踐性、適應(yīng)性特征建立起了多元的批評圖景。文化詩學(xué)強(qiáng)調(diào)重構(gòu)歷史文化語境,重視軼聞等非正統(tǒng)歷史資料對文本的闡釋的重要作用,重新詮釋歷史碎片中的文化圖景。文化詩學(xué)具有跨學(xué)科的特點(diǎn),尤其是與文化人類學(xué)具有親緣關(guān)系,文化詩學(xué)的批評實(shí)踐中常借鑒人類學(xué)的批評方法,其源頭可追溯到中國上世紀(jì)二三十年代的《詩經(jīng)》研究。中國比較文學(xué)學(xué)界提出"跨文化詩學(xué)",跨文化的對比研究也是文化詩學(xué)批評實(shí)踐中常運(yùn)用的方法,葉舒憲先生的"人類學(xué)三重證據(jù)法"及其"高唐神女"等的批評實(shí)踐對此有所印證。在《文藝復(fù)興時(shí)期的自我塑型》一書中,格林布拉特從創(chuàng)作主體角度提出了"自我塑型",表示作家與文本在社會歷史文化的宏大語境中進(jìn)行的雙向建構(gòu),這包含兩個(gè)過程,第一個(gè)過程是作家在話語實(shí)踐中實(shí)現(xiàn)主體地位的建構(gòu);第二個(gè)過程是在文本創(chuàng)作中完成對作家主體的塑型,蕭紅在其自傳性小說《呼蘭河傳》的創(chuàng)作中實(shí)現(xiàn)"自我塑型"。巴赫金提出的"外位性"概念與文化詩學(xué)具有共生關(guān)系,外位性顯示了作者在文學(xué)作品諸要素中的所處的特殊地位,為文化詩學(xué)的"作者"之維的研究拓展了思路。文化詩學(xué)認(rèn)為文本的概念不僅限于文學(xué)范疇之內(nèi),而是拓展到存在于一切人類實(shí)踐活動(dòng)的文化場域中的社會性文本,巴赫金的狂歡節(jié)研究即是典型。文學(xué)文本之間及其與社會性文本之間進(jìn)行廣泛互文,莎士比亞的劇作與馬洛的作品產(chǎn)生互文,《紅樓夢》中的"冷香丸"就是醫(yī)學(xué)文本與文學(xué)文本互文的結(jié)果。文本與歷史之間相互交融,"歷史的文本性"與"文本的歷史性"是新歷史主義文化詩學(xué)的重要理論范疇,也是其方法論的切入點(diǎn),馮內(nèi)古特的成名作《五號屠場》充分揭示了這兩個(gè)理論范疇的內(nèi)涵。社會生活的所有藝術(shù)文化文本都蘊(yùn)含著"驚嘆"和"共鳴"的特性,只有通過接收者文化的闡釋才能將其詩性品質(zhì)引發(fā)出來。權(quán)力話語影響讀者的審美內(nèi)容,以此達(dá)到影響讀者意識層面的目的,掃羅和大衛(wèi)王的形象變遷即是由權(quán)力話語主導(dǎo)而成。人們道德價(jià)值觀的轉(zhuǎn)變影響閱讀鑒賞活動(dòng)中接受主體的審美變遷,與此同時(shí)文化闡釋主體在閱讀鑒賞活動(dòng)時(shí)潛移默化地受到文本所蘊(yùn)含的倫理道德價(jià)值的影響,"耽美""百合"等網(wǎng)絡(luò)小說的流行對此有所印證。文化詩學(xué)認(rèn)為審美體驗(yàn)在讀者與文本的雙向交流和協(xié)調(diào)中得以實(shí)現(xiàn),讀者在闡釋的過程中能夠?qū)崿F(xiàn)文本意義的重建,同一文本,不同讀者的闡釋也有所不同,針對春晚小品《捐助》的紛爭恰與此契合。
[Abstract]:Greenblatt called cultural poetics "a practice, not a doctrine." Cultural poetics, with its practical methodology and adaptability, has set up a pluralistic view of criticism. Cultural poetics emphasizes the reconstruction of historical and cultural context and the important role of unorthodox historical materials such as anecdotes in the interpretation of texts and reinterprets the cultural picture in historical fragments. Cultural poetics has interdisciplinary characteristics, especially related to cultural anthropology. The criticism practice of cultural poetics often draws lessons from the critical methods of anthropology, the origin of which can be traced back to the study of the Book of songs in the 1920s and 1930s in China. The academic circles of Chinese comparative literature put forward "cross-cultural poetics", and cross-cultural comparative study is also a method often used in the practice of cultural poetics criticism. Ye Shuxian's Triple evidence Law of Anthropology and his critical practice of Gods and daughters of Gaotang have confirmed this. In the book "Self-Modification in the Renaissance", Greenblatt puts forward the "self-molding" from the perspective of the creative subject, which means the two-way construction of the writer and the text in the grand context of social history and culture, which includes two processes. The first process is the construction of the subjective position of the writer in the practice of discourse. The second process is to complete the shaping of the writer's main body in the text creation, and Xiao Hong to realize the "self-shaping" in the creation of his autobiographical novel "Hulan River Biography". The concept of "externality" put forward by Bakhtin has a symbiotic relationship with cultural poetics, which shows the special position of the author in the elements of literary works, and expands the thinking of the study of the "author" dimension of cultural poetics. Cultural poetics holds that the concept of text is not confined to the category of literature, but extends to the social text existing in the cultural field of all human practical activities. Bakhtin's Carnival study is typical. There are extensive intertextuals between literary texts and social texts. Shakespeare's plays and Marlowe's works produce intertextuals. "Lengxiang pills" in A Dream of Red Mansions is the result of intertextuality between medical texts and literary texts. Text and history are intermingled with each other. "the textuality of history" and "history of text" are the important theoretical categories of cultural poetics of new historicism and the breakthrough point of its methodology. Vonnegut's famous abattoir No. 5 fully reveals the connotation of these two theoretical categories. All the artistic and cultural texts of social life contain the characteristics of "wonder" and "resonance", which can only be triggered by the interpretation of the recipient's culture. Power discourse influences the aesthetic content of readers to achieve the purpose of influencing readers' consciousness. The image changes of Saul and King David are dominated by power discourse. The change of people's moral values affects the aesthetic changes of the subject in reading appreciation, while the cultural interpretation subject is influenced by the ethical and moral value contained in the text. The popularity of Internet novels such as Daimei and Lilium has confirmed this. Cultural poetics holds that aesthetic experience can be realized in the two-way communication and coordination between the reader and the text, the reader can reconstruct the meaning of the text in the process of interpretation, and different readers have different interpretations of the same text. In view of the Spring Festival Gala essay < donation > dispute is exactly in line with this.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：安徽大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：碩士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2017
【分類號】：I0
本文編號：2383843
[Abstract]:Greenblatt called cultural poetics "a practice, not a doctrine." Cultural poetics, with its practical methodology and adaptability, has set up a pluralistic view of criticism. Cultural poetics emphasizes the reconstruction of historical and cultural context and the important role of unorthodox historical materials such as anecdotes in the interpretation of texts and reinterprets the cultural picture in historical fragments. Cultural poetics has interdisciplinary characteristics, especially related to cultural anthropology. The criticism practice of cultural poetics often draws lessons from the critical methods of anthropology, the origin of which can be traced back to the study of the Book of songs in the 1920s and 1930s in China. The academic circles of Chinese comparative literature put forward "cross-cultural poetics", and cross-cultural comparative study is also a method often used in the practice of cultural poetics criticism. Ye Shuxian's Triple evidence Law of Anthropology and his critical practice of Gods and daughters of Gaotang have confirmed this. In the book "Self-Modification in the Renaissance", Greenblatt puts forward the "self-molding" from the perspective of the creative subject, which means the two-way construction of the writer and the text in the grand context of social history and culture, which includes two processes. The first process is the construction of the subjective position of the writer in the practice of discourse. The second process is to complete the shaping of the writer's main body in the text creation, and Xiao Hong to realize the "self-shaping" in the creation of his autobiographical novel "Hulan River Biography". The concept of "externality" put forward by Bakhtin has a symbiotic relationship with cultural poetics, which shows the special position of the author in the elements of literary works, and expands the thinking of the study of the "author" dimension of cultural poetics. Cultural poetics holds that the concept of text is not confined to the category of literature, but extends to the social text existing in the cultural field of all human practical activities. Bakhtin's Carnival study is typical. There are extensive intertextuals between literary texts and social texts. Shakespeare's plays and Marlowe's works produce intertextuals. "Lengxiang pills" in A Dream of Red Mansions is the result of intertextuality between medical texts and literary texts. Text and history are intermingled with each other. "the textuality of history" and "history of text" are the important theoretical categories of cultural poetics of new historicism and the breakthrough point of its methodology. Vonnegut's famous abattoir No. 5 fully reveals the connotation of these two theoretical categories. All the artistic and cultural texts of social life contain the characteristics of "wonder" and "resonance", which can only be triggered by the interpretation of the recipient's culture. Power discourse influences the aesthetic content of readers to achieve the purpose of influencing readers' consciousness. The image changes of Saul and King David are dominated by power discourse. The change of people's moral values affects the aesthetic changes of the subject in reading appreciation, while the cultural interpretation subject is influenced by the ethical and moral value contained in the text. The popularity of Internet novels such as Daimei and Lilium has confirmed this. Cultural poetics holds that aesthetic experience can be realized in the two-way communication and coordination between the reader and the text, the reader can reconstruct the meaning of the text in the process of interpretation, and different readers have different interpretations of the same text. In view of the Spring Festival Gala essay < donation > dispute is exactly in line with this.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：安徽大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：碩士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2017
【分類號】：I0
【參考文獻(xiàn)】
相關(guān)期刊論文 前10條
1 李琳;;“社會能量”的“流通”、“交換”與“協(xié)商”:格林布拉特的新歷史主義文藝觀新探[J];山東外語教學(xué);2015年01期
2 顧祖釗;;《禮記》尚古遺蹤初探——一種文化人類學(xué)解讀[J];復(fù)旦學(xué)報(bào)(社會科學(xué)版);2014年05期
3 張文濤;;文化詩學(xué)對話語的權(quán)力批判[J];閩南師范大學(xué)學(xué)報(bào)(哲學(xué)社會科學(xué)版);2014年03期
4 鄧京力;;語境與歷史之間——作為解釋模式與方法論前提的歷史語境理論[J];天津社會科學(xué);2013年02期
5 祖國頌;;雙向建構(gòu):一種文化詩學(xué)的闡釋策略——以“春晚”小品的爭議為例[J];漳州師范學(xué)院學(xué)報(bào)(哲學(xué)社會科學(xué)版);2012年04期
6 段建軍;;巴赫金生存詩學(xué)中的“自我”與“他人”[J];福建論壇(人文社會科學(xué)版);2011年07期
7 許勤超;;傳記寫作的互文性解釋策略——以格林布拉特的《俗世威爾:莎士比亞是如何成為莎士比亞的》為例[J];連云港師范高等�？茖W(xué)校學(xué)報(bào);2010年04期
8 徐岱;龍玉霞;;復(fù)調(diào)的生成——外位性思想與巴赫金的文化詩學(xué)[J];浙江大學(xué)學(xué)報(bào)(人文社會科學(xué)版);2010年04期
9 王進(jìn);;從文化闡釋到歷史厚描:文化人類學(xué)視域中的文化詩學(xué)批評[J];云南社會科學(xué);2010年03期
10 顧祖釗;;文化詩學(xué)倡導(dǎo)中的三個(gè)問題[J];燕趙學(xué)術(shù);2010年01期
相關(guān)博士學(xué)位論文 前1條
1 傅潔琳;格林布拉特新歷史主義與文化詩學(xué)研究[D];山東大學(xué);2008年
，本文編號：2383843
本文鏈接：http://sikaile.net/shoufeilunwen/zaizhiboshi/2383843.html
最近更新
教材專著
