【摘要】：[目的/意義]單篇研究論文直接評價在學(xué)術(shù)出版、科研管理中有廣泛應(yīng)用,目前最常見的單篇論文直接評價方法是多指標(biāo)加權(quán)評價法,該法存在指標(biāo)打分主觀性易過大、關(guān)鍵性指標(biāo)可能被非關(guān)鍵指標(biāo)掩蓋、創(chuàng)新性評價指標(biāo)細(xì)化不夠、論文分級區(qū)分度不夠等不足,對此提出一種新評價方法,抑制多指標(biāo)加權(quán)評價方法的上述不足,提高論文直接評價效度。[方法/過程]新方法將研究論文寫作中存在的典型問題直接納入評價指標(biāo)定義,各評價指標(biāo)采用定序尺度,各評價指標(biāo)分級之間兩兩組合,最終對應(yīng)到六個論文評價等級中的某一級。[結(jié)果/結(jié)論]新方法可用于自然工程、經(jīng)濟(jì)管理學(xué)科的期刊論文審稿和學(xué)位論文評議。
[Abstract]:Objective / significance: direct evaluation of single research paper is widely used in academic publication and scientific research management. At present, the most common direct evaluation method of single paper is multi-index weighted evaluation method. The key index may be concealed by non-key index, the innovative evaluation index is not detailed enough, the classification degree of the paper is not enough, and so on. A new evaluation method is put forward to restrain the deficiency of the multi-index weighted evaluation method. Improve the validity of direct evaluation. [method / process] the new method directly brings the typical problems in the research paper writing into the definition of evaluation index, each evaluation index adopts order scale, and each evaluation index is divided into two groups. Finally, it corresponds to one of the six evaluation levels. Results / conclusion the new method can be used in the review of journal papers and dissertations in natural engineering, economic management.
【作者單位】： 桂林電子科技大學(xué)商學(xué)院;
【基金】：國家自然科學(xué)基金“E-prints預(yù)印本數(shù)據(jù)庫環(huán)境下開放同行評議機(jī)制研究”(編號:71563007)
【分類號】：G312
，

本文編號：2246269