湯化龍與清末民初的政局
發(fā)布時間：2019-06-13 20:25
【摘要】：清術(shù)民初是憲政思想在中國迅速傳播、付諸試驗并遭受重大挫折的階段。清術(shù)立憲派和民初的進步黨、研究系一脈相承,作為關(guān)鍵性的力量參與了全過程。本論文的研究對象——湯化龍,作為該派的重要領(lǐng)袖,其政治生涯則與上述過程相始終。對其政治活動的考察,為我們觀察近代中國憲政進程的曲折展開提供了良好的視角。 湯化龍的政治生涯開始于1908年底,其時奉調(diào)回籍參與籌辦咨議局；結(jié)束于1917年底,其時作為段祺瑞內(nèi)閣成員連帶下野,次年秋在美游歷時遇刺身亡期間以辛亥革命和第一屆國會復(fù)會為界,可分為三個階段,大體為清術(shù)、袁世凱統(tǒng)治時期和段祺瑞統(tǒng)治時期。 憲政思想在19世紀(jì)術(shù)年被作為救亡手段傳入中國。清政府1906年宣布預(yù)備立憲,并于1907年諭令籌辦咨議局,為湯化龍這種既具有高等功名又通曉法政知識的新式士紳提供了廣闊的活動空間,并使其迅速登上地方和全國性的政治舞臺。省內(nèi)立憲派也很快以合法組織為依托,以咨議局為中心,以留日法政學(xué)生為骨干,聚集起來。咨議局作為立憲派的主要陣地,不僅積極維護、行使章程所賦予的權(quán)力,而且在國會請愿、拒債保路等社會性的運動中成為輿論中心和發(fā)動中心。咨議局開幕后,全國立憲派在請愿速開國會運動的推動下,通過召開各省咨議局議員聯(lián)合會、成立憲友會,自覺地實現(xiàn)了聯(lián)合。在清術(shù)立憲運動的洪流中,湯化龍一躍而成為全國知名的立憲派領(lǐng)袖人物,積累了較為豐富的議會實踐經(jīng)驗和廣泛的人脈。 民國成立,中國在經(jīng)濟與社會基礎(chǔ)沒有變化的條件下從西方移植了政黨、議會、內(nèi)閣等憲政框架。國民黨和進步黨進入國會,都希望通過在國會中占據(jù)多數(shù)進而組織一黨內(nèi)閣,但實權(quán)卻操縱在掌握北洋軍隊、排斥憲政理念的袁世凱手中。袁世凱以專制獨裁為目標(biāo),扶植、利用進步黨,打擊、驅(qū)逐國民黨；進步黨以“開明專制”為理念,依附、維護袁世凱,試圖上臺執(zhí)政。進步黨保有政治底線,在袁世凱露出帝制面目后決裂而去,與國民黨攜手抗袁,重返國會。在這一時期,湯化龍聚集起一批志同道合的舊立憲派骨干,在政黨和國會間互為依托,成為眾議院議長和進步黨領(lǐng)袖,與梁啟超并稱黨魁。湯、梁在黨內(nèi)各有淵源,而湯介入實際黨務(wù)較梁更深�！岸胃锩笔『�,湯化龍積極推動進步黨組閣,但結(jié)果卻無法貫徹本黨主張,且湯、梁因解散國民黨與國會事趨于分裂。湯化龍此后擔(dān)任教育總長,他尊孔,但反對中小學(xué)課讀全經(jīng),在此問題上不敵復(fù)古思潮,不安于位。其辭職和決定反袁的過程頗為曲折,反袁期間和梁啟超、孫洪伊各行其是。袁死之后,湯化龍進京疏通,督促段祺瑞下定決心恢復(fù)臨時約法與國會。 國會復(fù)會后,政治格局較袁前期有很大不同。國民黨與進步黨重返國會,以商榷系和研究系的形式進行對抗,且更加激烈；研究系居少數(shù),在國會議事和憲法會議中處處受到壓制。研究系沒有改變其扶助與引導(dǎo)“中心勢力”的政治路線,但對掌握政權(quán)的訴求降低,而一心支持段祺瑞。湯化龍向商榷系建議共同贊助段內(nèi)閣,并盡快完成制憲工作,以期國家憲政進入正軌,但事與愿違。府院之間、閣會之間、國會內(nèi)部黨派之間的沖突愈演愈烈,到1917年5月份,因參戰(zhàn)問題與制憲問題,矛盾爆發(fā)。湯化龍由于對國會極端失望,與段祺瑞(督軍團)結(jié)合主張解散國會,在張勛復(fù)辟被討平后也拒不恢復(fù),并召集臨時參議院,試圖修改國會組織法,改造國會,以達到在國會中占據(jù)多數(shù)的目的。這一企圖被軍閥輕易擊破,研究系完全失去政治活動空間。湯化龍曾是憲政的真誠追求者和國會的堅決維護者,強調(diào)循軌、秩序；最后卻不循軌、不守秩序,破壞憲政、解散國會,引發(fā)南北沖突。 論文共分為五章,湯化龍上述三個階段的政治活動,分別作為第二、四、五章。此外,第一章考察湯化龍的成長教育背景及其憲政思想的形成。第三章則考察湯化龍在武昌參與首義期間的活動,對其出山、任職、任事及出走的過程,做了詳細梳理。
[Abstract]:The early Qing Dynasty was the stage in which the constitutional thought spread rapidly in China, put to the test and suffered major setbacks. The party of the Qing Dynasty and the Progressive Party of the People's Republic of China, and the research department, participated in the whole process as a key force. As an important leader of the school, the research object of this paper, as the important leader of the school, is always the same as the above-mentioned process. The investigation of its political activities has provided a good perspective for us to observe the tortuous development of the modern Chinese constitutional process. The political career of the dragon began at the end of 1908, for the time being, for the time being, in the preparation of the Committee of the State of the Union; the end of the end of 1917, the time being, as a member of the section of the Cabinet, and the next year in the United States, the fall of the year was resumed at the Revolution of 1911 and the first session of the Congress. The boundary can be divided into three stages, which are mainly Qing-Shu, Yuan Shikai's reign and Duan's reign. In the 19th century, the thought of constitutionalism was transmitted as a means of saving and death. in 1906, that government of the Qing government announced the preparatory constitution, and in 1907, the government of the state-of-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-art gentry of the long-term and well-versed in the legal and political knowledge of the dragon provided a wide range of The constitutional government of the province is also based on the legal organization, with the State of the Union as the center, and the students of the law and administration of the day are the backbone and the poly. Set up. The State of the Union, as the main position of the constitutional group, not only actively maintains and exercises the powers conferred by the articles of association, but also becomes the centre and the hair of the public opinion in the social movements such as the petition of the Congress and the maintenance of the debt. The state-of-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-nation In the Hong flow of Qing-Shu's constitutional movement, the soup-long dragon has become a well-known constitutional leader in the whole country, and has accumulated rich experience and extensive experience in the Parliament. The People's Bank of China, established in the Republic of China, has transplanted political parties, parliaments and the cabinet from the West under the condition of no change in the economic and social basis When the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party go to Congress, the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party all want to adopt a majority in the Congress to organize a party's cabinet, but the real power is manipulated in the control of the military of the North and the rejection of the constitutional concept. Yuan Shikai was in the hands of Yuan Shikai. Yuan Shikai, with an autocratic and autocratic rule, promoted and used the Progressive Party to strike and expel the Kuomintang. The Progressive Party took the "enlightened despotism" as the concept, attached to it, and maintained Yuan Shikai. In power, the progressive party has a political bottom line, and after Yuan Shikai has revealed the face of the Emperor's face, it will break, and join hands with the Kuomintang to fight against it. In this period, the soup dragon gathered a group of like-minded old constitutional diaphysis, relying on each other between the political party and the Congress, and became the speaker of the House of Representatives and the leader of the Progressive Party, and Mr. Liang Qi The party has its own origins in the party, and the soup is involved in the actual party. After the "the second revolution" failed, the soup dragon actively promoted the progress party group, but the result was unable to carry out the party's claim, and the Tang and Liang were disbanded from the Kuomintang and the Congress Things tend to split. Mr. Tonghua has since served as the chief of the education, and he respected the hole, but opposed to the full-time reading of the primary and secondary school, on which the old thought of the old thought was not an enemy. The process of resigning and deciding the anti-dumping is rather tortuous, and the period of anti-dumping and Liang Qichao and Sun Hong After Yuan's death, Tang Huilong went to Beijing to dredge, and urged Mr. Duan to make up his mind to return to the interim. Congress and Congress. After the resumption of the Congress, the political structure is lower. In the early stage, the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party return to Congress to fight against the form of the system of discussion and research, and become more intense; the study is a minority, and in the proceedings of the National Assembly and the Constitutional Conference The study has not changed its political line to support and guide the "the central force", but the demand for the control of the regime is reduced, To support the section of the cabinet, Tang Huilong suggested to co-sponsor the cabinet of the section and to complete the constitution as soon as possible, with a view to the entry of the state's constitutional government into the right The conflict between the House and the House of Representatives and the internal party of the Congress is growing, and in May 1917, the issue of war and the constitution of the constitution The issue, the conflict broke out. Mr. Tonghua, as a result of the extreme disappointment of the Congress, combined with Mr. Duan's (the mission) for the release of the Congress, and refused to recover after Mr. Zhang's return, and called for a temporary Senate to try to amend the Organic Law of the National Assembly and to transform the Congress so as to be in the Congress To take up the majority of the purpose. The attempt was easily broken by the warlords, and the study was completely lost. To go to the space of political activity. The Tonghua dragon was the sincere suitor of the constitutional government and the firm defender of the Congress, and stressed the tracking and order; finally, it did not track, keep order, destroy the constitutional government, and demobilize the Congress. The paper is divided into five chapters, and the political activities of the three phases of Tonghua Dragon are divided into five chapters. As the second, the fourth and the fifth chapter. In addition, the first chapter examines the growth and education background of the Tang-long. The third chapter is to investigate the activities of the Tang-long in the first-meaning period of Wuchang's participation in the period of the first-meaning period, and to take stock, serve, and run away.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：復(fù)旦大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：博士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2012
【分類號】：K258
本文編號：2498797
[Abstract]:The early Qing Dynasty was the stage in which the constitutional thought spread rapidly in China, put to the test and suffered major setbacks. The party of the Qing Dynasty and the Progressive Party of the People's Republic of China, and the research department, participated in the whole process as a key force. As an important leader of the school, the research object of this paper, as the important leader of the school, is always the same as the above-mentioned process. The investigation of its political activities has provided a good perspective for us to observe the tortuous development of the modern Chinese constitutional process. The political career of the dragon began at the end of 1908, for the time being, for the time being, in the preparation of the Committee of the State of the Union; the end of the end of 1917, the time being, as a member of the section of the Cabinet, and the next year in the United States, the fall of the year was resumed at the Revolution of 1911 and the first session of the Congress. The boundary can be divided into three stages, which are mainly Qing-Shu, Yuan Shikai's reign and Duan's reign. In the 19th century, the thought of constitutionalism was transmitted as a means of saving and death. in 1906, that government of the Qing government announced the preparatory constitution, and in 1907, the government of the state-of-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-art gentry of the long-term and well-versed in the legal and political knowledge of the dragon provided a wide range of The constitutional government of the province is also based on the legal organization, with the State of the Union as the center, and the students of the law and administration of the day are the backbone and the poly. Set up. The State of the Union, as the main position of the constitutional group, not only actively maintains and exercises the powers conferred by the articles of association, but also becomes the centre and the hair of the public opinion in the social movements such as the petition of the Congress and the maintenance of the debt. The state-of-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-the-nation In the Hong flow of Qing-Shu's constitutional movement, the soup-long dragon has become a well-known constitutional leader in the whole country, and has accumulated rich experience and extensive experience in the Parliament. The People's Bank of China, established in the Republic of China, has transplanted political parties, parliaments and the cabinet from the West under the condition of no change in the economic and social basis When the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party go to Congress, the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party all want to adopt a majority in the Congress to organize a party's cabinet, but the real power is manipulated in the control of the military of the North and the rejection of the constitutional concept. Yuan Shikai was in the hands of Yuan Shikai. Yuan Shikai, with an autocratic and autocratic rule, promoted and used the Progressive Party to strike and expel the Kuomintang. The Progressive Party took the "enlightened despotism" as the concept, attached to it, and maintained Yuan Shikai. In power, the progressive party has a political bottom line, and after Yuan Shikai has revealed the face of the Emperor's face, it will break, and join hands with the Kuomintang to fight against it. In this period, the soup dragon gathered a group of like-minded old constitutional diaphysis, relying on each other between the political party and the Congress, and became the speaker of the House of Representatives and the leader of the Progressive Party, and Mr. Liang Qi The party has its own origins in the party, and the soup is involved in the actual party. After the "the second revolution" failed, the soup dragon actively promoted the progress party group, but the result was unable to carry out the party's claim, and the Tang and Liang were disbanded from the Kuomintang and the Congress Things tend to split. Mr. Tonghua has since served as the chief of the education, and he respected the hole, but opposed to the full-time reading of the primary and secondary school, on which the old thought of the old thought was not an enemy. The process of resigning and deciding the anti-dumping is rather tortuous, and the period of anti-dumping and Liang Qichao and Sun Hong After Yuan's death, Tang Huilong went to Beijing to dredge, and urged Mr. Duan to make up his mind to return to the interim. Congress and Congress. After the resumption of the Congress, the political structure is lower. In the early stage, the Kuomintang and the Progressive Party return to Congress to fight against the form of the system of discussion and research, and become more intense; the study is a minority, and in the proceedings of the National Assembly and the Constitutional Conference The study has not changed its political line to support and guide the "the central force", but the demand for the control of the regime is reduced, To support the section of the cabinet, Tang Huilong suggested to co-sponsor the cabinet of the section and to complete the constitution as soon as possible, with a view to the entry of the state's constitutional government into the right The conflict between the House and the House of Representatives and the internal party of the Congress is growing, and in May 1917, the issue of war and the constitution of the constitution The issue, the conflict broke out. Mr. Tonghua, as a result of the extreme disappointment of the Congress, combined with Mr. Duan's (the mission) for the release of the Congress, and refused to recover after Mr. Zhang's return, and called for a temporary Senate to try to amend the Organic Law of the National Assembly and to transform the Congress so as to be in the Congress To take up the majority of the purpose. The attempt was easily broken by the warlords, and the study was completely lost. To go to the space of political activity. The Tonghua dragon was the sincere suitor of the constitutional government and the firm defender of the Congress, and stressed the tracking and order; finally, it did not track, keep order, destroy the constitutional government, and demobilize the Congress. The paper is divided into five chapters, and the political activities of the three phases of Tonghua Dragon are divided into five chapters. As the second, the fourth and the fifth chapter. In addition, the first chapter examines the growth and education background of the Tang-long. The third chapter is to investigate the activities of the Tang-long in the first-meaning period of Wuchang's participation in the period of the first-meaning period, and to take stock, serve, and run away.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：復(fù)旦大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：博士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2012
【分類號】：K258
【參考文獻】
相關(guān)期刊論文 前10條
1 張國福;關(guān)于《中華民國臨時約法》的起草日期和主稿人問題——兼述《中華民國臨時約法》制訂過程[J];北京大學(xué)學(xué)報(哲學(xué)社會科學(xué)版);1984年01期
2 李書源;二次革命后的國會與黨爭[J];東北師大學(xué)報;1991年05期
3 郝幸艷;;李大釗與湯化龍民初關(guān)系探微[J];東華大學(xué)學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);2011年01期
4 劉道偉;試論湯化龍早期憲政思想的形成及實踐[J];湖北社會科學(xué);2005年06期
5 楊天石 ,王學(xué)莊;湯化龍密電辨訛——兼論湯化龍在武昌起義前后的政治表現(xiàn)[J];復(fù)旦學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);1981年05期
6 徐矛;;西方政制的引入與民國初年的政局[J];復(fù)旦學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);1987年05期
7 楊立強;論民國初年的政黨、黨爭與社會[J];復(fù)旦學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);1993年02期
8 姜義華;民初政黨政治與黃興民主政治思想的發(fā)展[J];復(fù)旦學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);1994年04期
9 黃俊軍;;清末立憲派近百年研究述評[J];湖南社會科學(xué);2006年06期
10 熊秋良;試析民初第一屆國會選舉[J];民國檔案;2005年04期
相關(guān)博士學(xué)位論文 前1條
1 蔡志榮;明清湖北書院研究[D];華中師范大學(xué);2008年
相關(guān)碩士學(xué)位論文 前1條
1 田丹;民初臨時參議院研究[D];湘潭大學(xué);2008年
，本文編號：2498797
本文鏈接：http://sikaile.net/shekelunwen/zgjxds/2498797.html
