諸葛亮木牛流馬制造地考辯
發(fā)布時間：2018-12-20 08:00
【摘要】："木牛、流馬"是諸葛亮的奇創(chuàng),對于它的研究一直延續(xù)至今,特別是它的制造地眾說紛紜,《三國志》、《水經(jīng)注》等說在"褒城縣黃沙戍",《通典》、《元和郡縣圖志》說在"景谷縣木馬山",《事物紀原》說在"江州",《三國演義》說在祁山附近的"上方谷"。通過考察辨析,提出:"木牛"和"流馬"不在同一時間、同一地方制造;《后主傳》與《元和郡縣圖志》的記載均可成立,二者沒有矛盾,即亮建興九年出祁山使用的"木牛"在利州景谷縣木馬山制造;建興十二年出斜谷使用的"流馬"在梁州褒城縣黃沙戍制作,其高承"創(chuàng)制于江州"和羅貫中"在上方谷制造"的斷言,或論據(jù)不足,或無據(jù)可考,皆不足為信。
[Abstract]:"Mu Niu, Liu Ma" is Zhuge Liang's unique creation. The research on it has continued to this day, especially in the place where it was manufactured. There are different opinions about it, such as "the Records of the three Kingdoms", "Water Classical Notes", etc., in "Huangsha garrison," and "Tongdian." "Yuan he County Tu Zhi" said in "Jinggu County Trojan Mountain", "things Ji Yuan" said in "Jiangzhou", "three Kingdoms" said in the Qishan near the "upper valley." Through investigation and analysis, it is proposed that "wooden cattle" and "Liu Ma" are not made at the same time and in the same place; "later master biography" and "Yuan he County Chronicles" records can be established, there is no contradiction between the two, that is, nine years of bright Jianxing Qishan use of "wooden cattle" in Jinggu County, Lizhou, made in the Trojan Mountain; The "Liu Ma", which was used for 12 years in Lianxing, was made in Huangsha, Liangzhou County, and its assertion that "created in Jiangzhou" and Luo Guanzhong "made in the upper valley", or insufficient arguments, or no evidence to be tested, are not enough to be believed.
【作者單位】： 中共蘭州市委黨校;
【分類號】：K236.2;K928.6
，
本文編號：2387690
[Abstract]:"Mu Niu, Liu Ma" is Zhuge Liang's unique creation. The research on it has continued to this day, especially in the place where it was manufactured. There are different opinions about it, such as "the Records of the three Kingdoms", "Water Classical Notes", etc., in "Huangsha garrison," and "Tongdian." "Yuan he County Tu Zhi" said in "Jinggu County Trojan Mountain", "things Ji Yuan" said in "Jiangzhou", "three Kingdoms" said in the Qishan near the "upper valley." Through investigation and analysis, it is proposed that "wooden cattle" and "Liu Ma" are not made at the same time and in the same place; "later master biography" and "Yuan he County Chronicles" records can be established, there is no contradiction between the two, that is, nine years of bright Jianxing Qishan use of "wooden cattle" in Jinggu County, Lizhou, made in the Trojan Mountain; The "Liu Ma", which was used for 12 years in Lianxing, was made in Huangsha, Liangzhou County, and its assertion that "created in Jiangzhou" and Luo Guanzhong "made in the upper valley", or insufficient arguments, or no evidence to be tested, are not enough to be believed.
【作者單位】： 中共蘭州市委黨校;
【分類號】：K236.2;K928.6
，
本文編號：2387690
本文鏈接：http://sikaile.net/shekelunwen/renwendili/2387690.html
